RestaurantsCoffee & Tea
Bagel Lady Cafe
Welcome to

Bagel Lady Cafe

About Bagel Lady Cafe

Bagel Lady Cafe is a welcoming restaurant and coffee shop in Shoreham, NY, serving customers at 99 NY-25A #18, Shoreham, NY 11786, United States. Known for breakfast, it offers a convenient way to enjoy a satisfying morning meal, a cup of coffee, or a quick stop during a busy day.

Whether you are looking for a relaxed dine-in experience, a meal to take with you, or food delivered to your location, the cafe provides several options to suit your plans.

Customers can choose from delivery, takeaway, dine-in, and on-site services, making Bagel Lady Cafe a practical choice for different schedules and preferences. Coffee is available to complement breakfast or provide a simple refreshment during a quick visit. The cafe also includes a restroom for added convenience, helping make each stop more comfortable and accommodating.

Accessibility is an important part of the customer experience, with a wheelchair-accessible car park, entrance, and toilet available on site. Payments are convenient as well, with credit cards, debit cards, and NFC mobile payments accepted.

With a customer rating of 4.10 out of 5 based on 352 reviews, Bagel Lady Cafe has earned positive feedback from many visitors. To place an order or learn more, call +1 631-744-0071.

★★★★☆ 4.10 rating (352 reviews)
0
Star Rating
0
Guest Reviews
0
Photos
0
Independent Reviews
Bagel Lady Cafe interior
Est. Local Favorite

A Taste of Tradition

Welcome to a place where great food meets warm hospitality. We believe dining is more than just a meal - it's an experience to be savored and shared.

Our kitchen is dedicated to creating dishes that bring people together, using recipes that honor tradition while embracing innovation.

  • Fresh Daily Specials
  • Private Dining Available
  • Catering Services
  • Takeout & Delivery

Guest Reviews

Hear from our valued guests

Jeff Yarmeisch

Jeff Yarmeisch

3 months ago

Meena and the staff went out of their way to make my employee appreciate day a total success. From the amazing bagels, to the cream cheeses and coffee. Thank you so very much everything was delicious

Carly Messina

Carly Messina

month ago

Best bagels in town hot and fresh and made to order. The owner is the kindest person and greets you with a beautiful smile and warm personality. You get treated like family.

Beau Gailey

Beau Gailey

month ago

Great bagels and breakfast options. When visiting family in Shoreham from Kansas City we always make a stop in for bagels and breakfast sandwiches.

John Tass-Parker (JTP)

John Tass-Parker (JTP)

4 months ago

Love this place. My wife and I were visiting friends in Shoreham and ended up going every day to visit this brilliant spot. Highly recommend the breakfast bagels and wraps. They have gluten free bagels as well that are very good.

Monica

Monica

year ago

This is our favorite deli to visit each time we’re back on the island visiting. The bagels are delicious and fresh and the sandwiches are great. The owner is a delight and always takes an interest in us and our plans. She goes above and beyond to put a smile on her customers’ faces. We love bagel lady and keep coming back year after year

Camille Morelli

Camille Morelli

year ago

I have been coming to this bagel store/deli forever. The owner and people that work there are always so friendly and accommodating. The food is always delicious and exactly how I ask for it. Bagels are always fresh. We went in today and asked for something new and not on the menu. She did it for us no problem, and it came out amazing. Bacon, egg, and cheese on a bagel with a burger. Incredible! Needless to say I will never go anywhere else for my breakfast sandwiches and bagels!

James DiGregorio

James DiGregorio

3 months ago

Love going to Meena’s! The bagels are always fantastic and fresh. Ordered 3 dozen bagels for my son’s party and got some bagel bites with them and they were a hit. Highly recommend this bagel place!!

Joey Pisto

Joey Pisto

month ago

This was one of the best bagels I have ever ate! The owner was so personable and took the time to have a wholesome conversation with my partner and I. We will absolutely be returning soon and telling everyone we know!!! 10/10

Beth Hoerner

Beth Hoerner

3 months ago

I’ve known Meena since I was about 5 years old, back when she had her other bagel shop location, and her bagels have always been some of my absolute favorites. Even though I moved away 10 years ago, every time I come back to visit, stopping in for one of her bagels is a must. The bagels are still just as amazing as I remember, and Meena is just as kind and welcoming. Highly recommend!

Ben Grodski

Ben Grodski

3 months ago

Best Bagels on the North Fork! I had 2 large orders needed for 5:30AM for my classroom and Meena easily accommodated me with fresh warm bagels that my students in Westhampton raved about. She also added some extras which was very sweet!

Frequently Asked Questions

Common questions about Bagel Lady Cafe

Business Features

Highlights & Amenities

Accessibility

  • Wheelchair-accessible car park
  • Wheelchair-accessible entrance
  • Wheelchair-accessible toilet

Service options

  • Delivery
  • On-site services
  • Takeaway
  • Dine-in

Offerings

  • Coffee

Dining options

  • Breakfast

Amenities

  • Restroom

Planning

  • Quick visit

Payments

  • Credit cards
  • Debit cards
  • NFC mobile payments

Parking

  • Free parking lot

Visit Us

We look forward to welcoming you. Make a reservation or stop by - walk-ins welcome!

Location

99 NY-25A #18, Shoreham, NY 11786, United States

Reservations

+1 631-744-0071

Hours

Open Now · Sunday 6 AM-3 PM
Tuesday 5:30 AM-4 PM
Wednesday 5:30 AM-4 PM
Thursday 5:30 AM-3 PM
Friday 5:30 AM-4 PM
Saturday 6 AM-3 PM
Sunday 6 AM-3 PM
Monday 5:30 AM-4 PM
Share This Business

Make a Reservation

Request a table and we'll confirm your booking shortly.